The tech brand’s latest tongue-in-cheek film, Reply All is Scary, transforms one of the internet’s most relatable nightmares into a haunted house of email chaos, starring comedian Steph Barkley.
Is there anything more chilling than realising you’ve hit “Reply All” on a 50-person email chain? Just in time for Halloween, Yahoo! is embracing the horror with a tongue-in-cheek short film titled ‘Reply All is Scary’, a comical yet all-too-familiar tale of digital dread.
The film stars comedian and creator Steph Barkley as a woman who is quite literally haunted by her inbox, as the recipients of her accidental reply start materialising in her home. It’s a lighthearted parody of classic horror tropes, from eerie lighting and glitchy sound effects to the creeping sense of panic that anyone who’s ever made an email mishap will instantly recognise.
Released across Yahoo’s Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook channels, the short continues the brand’s growing series of playful films that turn modern tech frustrations into creative storytelling moments.
“We absolutely love playing with true tech insights, especially the frustrations and tension points that we all know and feel as an online society,” says Yahoo’s Creative Lab Director, Kemma Kefalas. “The idea started with a question – ‘what if we made a Halloween costume of an email horror?’ – and spiralled into one of the scariest things that can happen to someone on email: accidentally replying all.”
The witty, self-aware horror spoof also doubles as a nod to Yahoo Mail’s long-standing role in people’s digital lives. “We’ve all been on one end of this scenario at some point,” adds Kemma. “It felt like a subtle way to connect with people by showing them that hey, Yahoo Mail feels the pain and we’re here to help.”
Yahoo’s Creative Lab has made a name for itself by turning everyday digital irritations into moments of levity. Earlier this year, it released Attach-mints – real mints for those who forget to attach files – and a touch grass keyboard for people who need to, quite literally, log off and touch grass. There was even an Anti-Email Email Club streetwear collaboration for those tired of constant notifications.
“One of Yahoo’s biggest differentiators as a technology brand is that we have a sense of humour and playful side,” says Kemma. “Creatively, we’re not afraid to have fun or do things a bit differently.”
Yahoo’s willingness to poke fun at the digital experience has become central to Yahoo’s brand personality. It’s a mix of nostalgia, relevance, and relatability that definitely helps cut through the tech sector’s often overly polished tone.
Kemma believes that, when done right, humour can be more than a creative gimmick. In fact, she sees it as a strategic bridge between human emotion and digital experience.
“Tech is such an integral part of all of our daily lives. We need it, we love it, and in Yahoo’s case, we literally are it — 90% of people in the US use Yahoo each month!” she says. “But we really love bringing a human touch to that, and humour is a lighthearted yet powerful way to connect with people.”
Balancing that levity with brand messaging takes subtlety, though. “Sometimes the brand or product messaging is subtle, like Reply All is Scary, which quickly flashes Yahoo Mail on Steph’s laptop before moving on,” Kemma explains. “Sometimes it’s more overt. But the balance comes from making sure the story always leads back to something authentic about how people use tech every day.”
The film’s concept emerged from a Creative Lab Halloween brainstorm that began with the question: What would a Yahoo Halloween costume look like?
“It was a funny brainstorm because, after all, what does something intangible like Yahoo look like?” Kemma recalls. “After some noodling, we ended up navigating away from costumes and onto what something scary would feel like? Of all the digital scaries, we landed on ‘Reply All’ as the winner.”
To bring the idea to life, Yahoo collaborated with Conscious Minds Studios, which wrote, directed, and produced the short. Steph Barkley – known for her quick-witted online sketches – was cast in the lead role. “She’s hilarious,” says Kemma. “They wrote a killer concept and brought it to life perfectly.”
While Reply All is Scary fits neatly into the brand’s annual Halloween slot, it also signals a broader commitment to storytelling-led campaigns.
Kemma says: “You can absolutely expect to see more storytelling-led work.
“We don’t sell a product you can hold – unless grass keyboards count – we offer experiences. Storytelling is one of the greatest opportunities we have to relate to our audiences, make them smile, and ideally drive consideration.”
If nothing else, the short is comical and shows that, even in an age of AI and automation, the most haunting tech moments are still the very human ones. Reply All is Scary is now live on Yahoo’s social channels (best watched with the lights on).
Leave a Reply